TOPIC:

Any help identifying this font would be greatly appreciated. The software isn't catching this one for some reason.

Hi,

Find my Font does identify this font correctly as Mr Dafoe (Regular)

Imagine that. I browsed through over 4700 fonts and couldn't find it. When I copied your letters into FMF, all it gave me was Edwardian Scripts. It did not find the Mr. Dafoe font family. I wonder if it was because you already had it as a system font?

System and installed fonts are displayed with green background while online matches are displayed with light red background.
As you can see in my screenshot Mr Dafoe was matched online (I don't have it on my computer).

If you selected the same letters, you should get the same response. If you're not getting Mr Dafoe as one of the top matched fonts then you're doing something wrong.
Send me a screenshot of the Find my Font app and I'll tell you what is wrong.

My apologies. It was there.